Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania suggested on Saturday that he could leave the Democratic Party if Senate Democrats pick Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen as their next leader, pointing to Van Hollen's criticism of Israel.
Asked by Fox News host Kayleigh McEnany on “Saturday in America” whether there was a “red line” that could push him out of the party, Fetterman said: “Yeah, absolutely. It would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen, that has really made his name being very hostile to Israel.”
In the clip, Fetterman names Van Hollen directly when McEnany asks what would cross the line for him. Pressed on whether he would actually switch parties, he stopped short of a firm answer: “Well, I don't know how that's going to look, but I am a Democrat. I've always said that.”
A leadership fight after the midterms
Van Hollen announced on Thursday that he would run for Senate majority leader, challenging New York's Chuck Schumer days after Democrats won control of the chamber in the midterm elections. Progressive lawmakers including Sen. Bernie Sanders back the bid, while Schumer says he has the votes to stay on. Senate Democrats are expected to hold a closed-door leadership election in early December.
Fetterman said he did not see a path for Van Hollen but called it “possible,” noting that protesters had demanded he vote against Schumer. “After our massive wins, we immediately go back to fighting among ourselves. Can't we just, you know, take the win?” he said. Apart from Israel and his trip to El Salvador to meet deported migrant Kilmar Abrego Garcia, “I can't really think of what Van Hollen's known for,” Fetterman added.
He said he hopes to work with the White House on the national debt, artificial intelligence, Iran and Social Security. “My hope is that our party doesn't revert to our worst impulses,” he said.
“Why not make that Iran?”
Fetterman's sharpest words were about Israel. “I have a strong, strong difference of opinion on Israel and the Jewish community overall now. I don't think there's going to be any more common ground,” he said, adding that Iran is “committed to destroying Israel and our nation as well.”
In the second clip, Fetterman asks why fellow Democrats aim their anger at Israel instead of Iran, Hezbollah or Hamas. “If you are going to be angry or hostile towards any countries in the region, why not make that Iran? Or Hezbollah? Or Hamas as well too?” he says. “And now why, why, both in the House and in the Senate, are their first instincts to punish Israel and withhold these kinds of aid?”
His remarks come days after 12 senators led by Van Hollen asked congressional leaders to strip three provisions from the fiscal 2027 defense bill that would require deeper U.S. defense and intelligence cooperation with Israel.
Fetterman, who has broken with his party on the Iran war and voted with Republicans on several issues, also faces a 2028 primary challenge from Ahmed Moor, a Gaza-born Palestinian American writer. Only 13% of Pennsylvania Democrats approve of Fetterman's job performance, compared with 72% of Pennsylvania Republicans, according to a poll released last month cited by the Daily Beast.
Video: Fox News. Photo via New York Post