Two senior House Democrats are demanding answers from the U.S. Navy after the service relieved the entire command team of a nuclear-powered attack submarine without telling Congress, one of several quiet removals that break with the Navy's long practice of announcing such changes.
Rep. Joe Courtney of Connecticut, the top Democrat on the House Armed Services seapower subcommittee, and Rep. Adam Smith of Washington, the committee's ranking member, wrote Thursday to acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Daryl Caudle. "We write to express deep frustration over the Navy's failure to notify the House Armed Services Committee of the relief of the Commanding Officer, Executive Officer, and Chief of the Boat of the USS South Dakota (SSN 790) on October 14, 2026," the letter said, according to Stars and Stripes.

Submarine Force Atlantic confirmed this week that Cmdr. Daniel Goodwin, who took command of the Virginia-class boat on June 30, was relieved over a "loss of confidence in his ability to fulfill his assigned duties." Executive officer Lt. Cmdr. Jacqueline Penichet and chief of the boat Senior Chief Jon Nogaj were removed the same day. The Navy confirmed the move only after The Day of New London, Connecticut, reported it.
A reported brush with the seabed
The lawmakers' letter says the submarine reportedly struck something on the seabed and asks the Navy to clarify whether South Dakota had a "grounding or other mishap at sea." The Navy has not confirmed any incident and declined to comment on the personnel action. Clues surfaced in a commendation for a crew member, which said that during a September deployment the sailor recognized that "the rate of shoaling water presented an immediate navigational hazard to the ship" and raised the alarm in time. The submarine returned to its homeport in Groton, Connecticut, on Oct. 22.
"The Navy's lack of transparency leave many outstanding questions about not only what occurred, but the impact of the events leading the triad's dismissal on the structural health of South Dakota, the well-being of the crew, and whether the incident laid bare any systemic issues with training to standard procedures that must be addressed," Courtney and Smith wrote. They asked for answers by Nov. 20. No statute requires such notices, the lawmakers acknowledged, but the Navy kept Congress informed after the USS Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain collisions and the USS Hartford and USS Connecticut groundings.
Other quiet removals
The Associated Press reported that the South Dakota case is not the only one. The Navy relieved Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham, commander of the destroyer USS Michael Murphy, on Sept. 27 for a loss of confidence after less than a year in command; a Navy spokesperson later confirmed the relief to USNI News. The destroyer has been deployed to support operations against Iran. The service issued no announcement.

Rear Adm. Brian Monahan, a Navy doctor who served for nearly 18 years as attending physician to Congress and the Supreme Court, has also left his post amid a Navy investigation, the AP reported, with no public announcement. Sens. Mike Rounds, R-S.D., and Alex Padilla, D-Calif., confirmed his departure but gave few details.
The dispute could complicate Cao's confirmation hearing next week, as he seeks to become the Navy's top civilian official on a permanent basis.
Photos: U.S. Navy (John Narewski) via Stars and Stripes; U.S. Navy via Clash Report and Wikimedia Commons