Nicolás Maduro's defense team, led by Washington trial lawyer Barry Pollack, is asking a federal judge in New York to throw out the U.S. drug-trafficking case against the former Venezuelan leader, arguing that he is immune from prosecution as a sitting head of state, Politico reported. A new judge, Analisa Torres, is set to hold her first hearing in the case in mid-December.
Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, were seized in a U.S. military operation in Caracas on Jan. 3 and flown to New York. At his arraignment in Manhattan two days later, he pleaded not guilty and declared: "I am president of the republic of Venezuela, and I am here, kidnapped."

'No court has ever held…'
In a filing asking the court to dismiss the case, Pollack and fellow defense lawyer Anna Estevao wrote: "No court has ever held that a foreign leader recognized by his own country as the sitting head of state can be arrested to be subjected to jurisdiction because the forum has failed politically to recognize him." They also argue that his conduct should count as protected "official acts," citing the Supreme Court's 2024 ruling that expanded presidential immunity for Donald Trump.
Prosecutors in the Manhattan U.S. attorney's office counter that Maduro has not been a legitimate leader since January 2019, when Washington last recognized him as president. "The Executive Branch has sole authority to determine who is a foreign head of state," they wrote. They note that the only U.S. district court to weigh such a claim in a criminal case, in the prosecution of Panama's Manuel Noriega, deferred fully to the executive branch.
The lawyer who ended the Assange saga
Pollack, a former president of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, represented Assange for nearly 15 years and in 2024 guided him to a guilty plea on a single count that secured his release from a British prison. Estevao worked on the defense team of Sean "Diddy" Combs. Pollack declined to comment to Politico.

Maduro and Flores face charges including narco-terrorism, conspiracy to import cocaine and weapons offenses. Last month prosecutors added allegations that the couple tortured detainees, including American citizens, which Maduro has called false. The trial is set for June 14, 2027, and the case passed to Torres after Judge Alvin Hellerstein died in October at 92.
Lawyers on both sides say the ruling will set a precedent either way. Renato Stabile, who represented former Honduran President Juan Orlando Hernández, pointed to the risks for Washington itself: "It's quite extraordinary to go into a foreign country and seize a world leader. I'm sure there are countries that would love to come into the U.S. and seize President Trump," he told Politico.
Photos: Wikimedia Commons (NYU FC, CC BY-SA 3.0; Joe Ravi, CC BY-SA 3.0).